Broker- Dealer Law Corner

Broker- Dealer Law Corner

Category Archives: Administrative Proceedings

Subscribe to Administrative Proceedings RSS Feed

SEC ALJs, Part 3: Separation Of Power/Removal Defense Rides On Coattails Of Reinvigorated Appointments Clause Defense

Posted in Administrative Proceedings, Defenses, Disciplinary Process, SEC
In my second post on constitutionally-based affirmative defenses to SEC administrative proceedings, I discussed the shift of momentum in favor of the defense that the process of hiring SEC ALJs violates the Appointments Clause of the U.S. Constitution. This post examines the defense that the process of removing SEC ALJs violates the separation of power… Continue Reading

Article II Appointments Clause Defense To SEC Administrative Actions Gains Momentum In The Courts

Posted in Administrative Proceedings, appeal, Dodd Frank, SEC
Here is Part II of Ken Berg’s analysis of constitutional defenses that have been raised in response to the SEC’s increased use of administrative proceedings.  In the interest of full disclosure, note that the Malouf case referenced towards the end is one that Heidi VonderHeide and I are handling.  In addition, it also worth mentioning… Continue Reading

No Surprise Here: Courts Take Constitutional Complaints About SEC Administrative Prosecutions More Seriously Than The SEC

Posted in Administrative Proceedings, Defenses, SEC
This is the first in a series of posts by my partner, Ken Berg, discussing the constitutional defenses to SEC administrative enforcement actions, which we are called upon regularly to defend. Each subsequent post will discuss one of the constitutional issues and report the current state of the law as to that defense.  Ken’s next… Continue Reading

2017 Off To A Bad Start For The SEC As The 10th Circuit Finds SEC ALJs To Be Unconstitutional

Posted in Administrative Proceedings, Disciplinary Process, Enforcement, SEC
Many industry authors – including me[1] – have devoted a lot of attention lately to the SEC’s increased use of Administrative Proceedings (rather than Federal court cases) in recent years, and questioned the fairness of such proceedings, given their relative lack of discovery tools, the short timeframe provided within which to prepare a case for… Continue Reading

Looking For A Silver Lining: Post-Election Thoughts On The SEC

Posted in Administrative Proceedings, appeal, Disciplinary Process, Enforcement, SEC
Wednesday morning marked the confluence of two events. First, like the rest of the world, I awoke to the reality of the results of the presidential race.  Then, as soon as I got to the office, I received the results of a case (on which I have previously blogged) that the SEC’s Division of Enforcement… Continue Reading

It’s Official: The SEC Has No Sense Of Humor

Posted in Administrative Proceedings, Disciplinary Process, Enforcement, SEC
One of my colleagues and I were busy the last two week defending an SEC administrative proceeding out-of-town, so I have not had much chance to blog. But…there was one development during our hearing that merits some immediate attention. My client has been accused, essentially, of making a number of material misrepresentations and omissions in… Continue Reading

Updates: Two Losers + One Positive Note = A Bad Week For Broker-Dealers

Posted in Administrative Proceedings, appeal, Disciplinary Process, Enforcement, FINRA, Research analyst, Rule 2242, Rule 2711, SEC
There have been some developments this week in a few matters on which I have previously offered my views. To help you stay on the cutting edge of financial world current events as you mingle at your upcoming Cinco de Mayo fiestas, here are three updates.  Two, not surprisingly, represent wins for the regulators.  The… Continue Reading

The First Circuit Makes The Case Against Cherry-Picking Instances Of Alleged Misrepresentations By Focusing, Instead, On “Context”

Posted in 17(a)(3), Administrative Proceedings, appeal, Defenses, Enforcement, FINRA, SEC
Years ago, I handled the defense of a FINRA Enforcement case that still galls me.  The client sent a series of emails, over many months, about a particular security to customers who already owned the stock.  The point of the emails was largely to provide updates, and, from time-to-time, to suggest that the customers consider… Continue Reading

The SEC’s Proposal To Improve The Fairness Of Administrative Proceedings: Not Nearly Enough To Impact Its Winning Percentage, But Enough To Make It Seem It Cares

Posted in Administrative Proceedings, appeal, SEC
In what many will likely consider to be an effort to quiet the increasing chorus of criticism over the SEC’s increased use of administrative proceedings over the last few years, today, the SEC announced a proposal to amend several of the rules governing those proceedings. While the SEC did not expressly acknowledge that the amendments… Continue Reading

Compliance Officer Liability: Findings Without Sanctions? The Plot Thickens

Posted in Administrative Proceedings, appeal, Compliance, Enforcement, RIA, Sanctions, SEC, Supervision
We have previously posted on the issue of CCO liability, a very sensitive subject, to say the least, for many readers of this blog.  If this is a subject that interests you, then there was a very intriguing development this past week in this area that merits your attention. It came in the form of… Continue Reading

David Slays Goliath…And Goliath Is Pissed

Posted in Administrative Proceedings, appeal, Disciplinary Process, Enforcement, Sanctions, SEC
I reported a few weeks ago on the victory that my clients, Mark Robare and Jack Jones, achieved in the administrative proceeding that the SEC initiated against them last year. Against all odds, they convinced Judge Grimes that not only had they not committed the fraud claimed by the SEC, but, in Judge Grimes’ words,… Continue Reading

SEC Publishes Memo Explaining Its Forum Selection Considerations, But Questions Remain

Posted in Administrative Proceedings, SEC
The SEC has faced mounting criticism recently for its increasing use of administrative proceedings in enforcement matters. Numerous lawsuits have been filed against the agency, challenging its forum selection. Judge Jed Rakoff of the U.S. District for the Southern District of New York has made it very clear he has serious fairness and constitutionality concerns… Continue Reading
.